Review and negotiate a Deed of Settlement and Release
Before you sign that deed, we read it.
A Deed of Settlement and Release closes off every claim you have against your employer in exchange for a one-time payment. The amount is one thing. The release scope, the restraints, the non-disparagement clauses, the tax treatment, and the things you give up that nobody mentioned are equally important. We read the deed against the actual matter, calculate what the settlement is really worth, negotiate the gaps, and rewrite the terms so signing the deed protects you instead of stripping you.
What is a Deed of Settlement and Release and why does it matter?
A Deed of Settlement and Release is a contract that ends a dispute on a no-admissions basis. Under the deed, one party (usually the employer) pays a settlement sum, and the other (usually the employee) releases every claim that exists or might exist out of the employment relationship, on the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and at common law. Deeds are legally binding from signature and almost impossible to set aside once signed. They commonly include confidentiality, non-disparagement, mutual or one-way restraints, and detailed tax characterisation of the payment. The terms control what you can ever say, sue for, or recover from the employer again.
Is a Deed of Settlement and Release legally binding?
Yes. A deed is binding from signature and can only be set aside in narrow circumstances such as undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation, or unconscionable conduct, and the threshold for each is high. The realistic position is that once you sign the deed, you are bound by its terms.
What am I giving up when I sign the release?
A standard release closes off every claim you have, or might have, against the employer arising out of the employment relationship. That includes unfair dismissal, general protections, discrimination, breach of contract, underpayment, personal injury, and any claims relating to entitlements such as super or equity. Without carve-outs, you may also be releasing claims you do not yet know about.
What other terms commonly appear in the deed?
Confidentiality (you cannot disclose the terms), non-disparagement (you cannot say negative things about the employer), post-employment restraints (limits on competing, soliciting, or hiring), tax treatment of the payment, and a bar to commencing proceedings. Restraints and non-disparagement clauses are often drafted to run only one way; we negotiate them to run both ways.
Can I negotiate the deed once it has been sent to me?
Almost always. The first version of a deed is rarely the final position. We negotiate the settlement amount, narrow the release scope, narrow or waive the restraints, make the non-disparagement mutual, and calibrate the tax treatment. Most deeds change materially between the first draft and the signed version.
Settlement amount checked.
We calculate the real value of the matter and negotiate the gap.
Release scope narrowed.
Carve-outs preserved for claims that should not be released.
Restraints made workable.
Non-disparagement made mutual, restraints narrowed to what is enforceable.
Got a deed in front of you? Do not sign it yet.
Most deeds materially improve between the first draft and the signed version. The first call tells you whether the settlement amount is fair and what to negotiate.
They sent the deed. You have until Friday.
You have a deed of release in your inbox, a settlement number that may or may not reflect what your matter is worth, and a deadline to sign. You do not know what claims you are giving up, whether the restraints are enforceable, or what happens when you sign something that closes off claims you may not have realised you had.
- We will calculate what the matter is actually worth and benchmark it against the settlement amount on offer.
- We will read every clause of the deed and identify what you are giving up beyond the obvious release.
- We will narrow the release scope with carve-outs for claims that should not be released.
- We will negotiate restraints down to what is enforceable, or waive them where they would block your next role.
- We will make the non-disparagement clause run both ways and negotiate the tax treatment of the payment.
The deed has landed and the deadline is real.
The employer has sent over a Deed of Settlement and Release with a number and a date. The number is meaningful but you are not sure it reflects the full value of the matter. The restraint clauses are wider than you would like, the non-disparagement clause runs only against you, and the release covers every imaginable claim. You have a week to sign, and you need someone to tell you what is normal, what is not, and what to push back on.
What's included in your deed review and negotiation service
- Settlement amount benchmarking against the value of the matter.
- Full review of every clause: release, restraints, confidentiality, non-disparagement, tax, undertakings.
- Carve-outs negotiated for claims that should not be released.
- Restraints narrowed or waived.
- Non-disparagement made mutual.
- Tax treatment calibrated for the most efficient outcome.
- Negotiation correspondence with the employer's lawyers.
- Final review and signing.
What you lose when you sign a deed without advice.
Employees sign deeds of release with terms they did not understand more often than any other category of legal document. The settlement amount looks reasonable so the rest of the document does not get read carefully. The release is broad enough to close off underpayment, super, and equity claims that were never investigated. The restraint clauses extend the original employment contract restraints, or add new ones that were not in the original deal. The non-disparagement clause runs only one way and stops the employee discussing what actually happened, even with their next employer. By the time any of this becomes a problem, the deed has been signed and the law treats it as binding.
Here is how we rewrite the deed so it protects you both ways.
We start by benchmarking the settlement amount against the actual value of the matter, then go through every clause of the deed to identify the terms that need to change. Where the release is too broad, we add carve-outs for unpaid super, accrued equity, and personal injury claims that have not been investigated. Where the restraints would block your next role, we narrow them to what is actually enforceable, or waive them in exchange for a modest settlement bump. The non-disparagement clause is rewritten to run both ways. By the time the deed is signed, the terms reflect what was actually negotiated and what you walk away with is properly characterised and properly paid out.
Three steps to a deed that actually protects you.
Benchmark, negotiate, sign.
1
Benchmark complete.
We calculate the real value of the matter and compare it to the settlement amount on the table.
2
Deed terms negotiated.
We negotiate the release scope, the restraints, the non-disparagement, and the tax treatment.
3
Settlement closed.
We finalise the deed, walk you through the signing, and confirm payment.
Employment lawyers who review and negotiate deeds of release for employees.
Signing a Deed of Settlement and Release closes the chapter on the employment, and unwinding the deed afterwards is almost impossible. We have reviewed and negotiated hundreds of employment deeds across industries from frontline staff to senior executives, and the pattern is consistent: the deeds that go in unreviewed leave money on the table and impose terms that surface as problems later. Our team benchmarks the settlement, negotiates the gap, and rewrites the clauses that need rewriting. You sign a deed that ends the matter cleanly, protects what you walk away with, and does not lock you out of your industry afterwards.
We understand you want to know the cost, before we get started...
We will map out our process, from beginning to end, so you know what the journey will look like before you get started.
We will provide you with a clear and detailed Work Proposal covering each step along the way.
Our fair fees are all-inclusive. No hidden costs for telephone calls, emails, photocopying, couriers, or coffee.
Get the deed reviewed before you sign.
Related articles
Read more about deeds of release, settlement negotiation, and how JFM Law can help.
