Is Genuine Redundancy A Redundant Concept?

When employers engage with a genuine redundancy, it is important for them to note their obligations.

Redundancies are often a sensitive but necessary option for employers to take if the role being filled is no longer required.

In an unfair dismissal context, section 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) provides that a person’s dismissal will be considered to be a ‘genuine’ redundancy if the employer has made a decision that it no longer requires the person’s job to be performed by anyone, due to changes in the operational requirements of the employer’s enterprise.

More often than not, a genuine redundancy masks issues of poor performance or misconduct. This is a discrepancy that needs to be addressed and dealt with effectively to ensure unfair dismissal applications are not lodged with the Fair Work Commission.

Primarily, the employer must check the terms and conditions of their employment contract and any redundancy policies that the employer may have. However, the primary obligations in respect of a redundancy arise from a statutory source which is the Fair Work Act 2009 and the relevant award of that employees services.

As redundancy is a common occurrence in many companies, it is important to have systems in place that ensure the emotional concerns of the employee are adequately met. Often this requires the engagement of more than just the Human Resources Department, but additional support services.

For a genuine redundancy to be executed successfully, there must be clear passages of communication from employee to employer. Communication is key to avoid inaccurate information circulating around the office as this can be highly damaging and negatively impact the redundancy process.

It is the HR Managers who will have the most regular contact with the redundant employment and it vital for them to make themselves available for questions and queries as the need arises.

Genuine redundancy varies between industries and award and it is important for employers to be across their rights and obligations to ensure they comply with the Fair Work Act 2009. Are you a business owner or HR Manager and confused about your obligations in relation to redundancy? Contact JFM Law on (02) 9199 8597 for a no obligation chat. If you would rather get in contact through email, send your question through or by email at wehelp@jfmlaw.com.au.

More information

Join our ADLV Law team as we answer your FAQs about Redundancy. To access the transcript, click here.

How Individual Flexibility Arrangements Can Benefit Your Business

How Individual Flexibility Arrangements Can Benefit Your Business

In today’s fast-evolving business landscape, ‘flexibility’ is a necessity. Employers are constantly seeking ways to balance operational demands with employee needs while staying compliant with workplace laws. One effective tool for achieving this balance is the Individual Flexibility Arrangement (IFA). 

read more
A Cautionary Tale About Incorporating Workplace Policies and Procedures into Employment Contracts

A Cautionary Tale About Incorporating Workplace Policies and Procedures into Employment Contracts

Do you know if your workplace procedures and policies form part of your employment agreements with your staff?  You might want to check… 

The High Court’s recent decision in Elisha v Vision Australia (Elisha) has significant implications for employers who incorporate workplace procedures and policies into employment contracts.  Mr Elisha, an employee of Vision Australia, was dismissed following an investigation into alleged misconduct. The investigation process failed to adhere to the company’s own disciplinary procedure, which was incorporated into Mr Elisha’s employment contract. 

read more
Navigating Christmas Shutdowns: An Employer’s Guide to Annual Leave

Navigating Christmas Shutdowns: An Employer’s Guide to Annual Leave

The festive season brings joy, family time, and… the yearly headache of managing the Christmas shutdown.  One of the biggest challenges is annual leave.  The rules have changed in recent years, and these changes have shifted the power dynamic regarding shutdown leave; importantly, employers can no longer require employees to take unpaid leave over the Christmas shutdown. 

read more